Spies & Lies
When discussing the USA Patriot Act, it is common for defenders to jump on the 9/11 argument. That is, mass surveillance - including collecting metadata and other information from U.S. citizens - is warranted in order to protect national security and prevent another massive terrorist attack, like the 9/11 attacks.
There are several convincing (at least, to me) counterarguments to this line of reasoning:
1) There is no evidence that mass surveillance has uncovered and foiled any plot like the 9/11 attacks, and "plots" that have been foiled are often questionable. Sometimes, scarily so.
2) Mass surveillance isn't something that started post-9/11 - the DEA was tracking calls for a decade beforehand - and mass surveillance didn't stop 9/11 because mass surveillance isn't actually very good for looking for terrorist plots.
3) Mass surveillance under the Patriot Act isn't really about terrorism, anyway. It's about drugs. At least, that's how it's actually being used. It's used for a failing War on Drugs, and shouting "Terrorism!" is, at best, misleading the public.
4) There's a lot of irrelevant (to the government) information to dig through, and it just keeps piling up. That makes it harder for agencies to actually find real terrorist plots (or, for that matter, big drug deals). It's a bit like saying, "Hey, guys, I dropped my keys in this pile of elephant poop right here, and now I can't find them. Can you rake some more poop from all over the circus over here for me to dig through?" You're going to have a harder time finding what you need, and you're going to get really filthy doing it.
5) Lastly, and most importantly, suspicionless mass surveillance is a violation our rights to free speech and to privacy. The government has no legal right to interfere with our right to communicate with each other, even if that communication is revolutionary or otherwise unpleasant to the government. The government also has no moral right to invade our privacy and collect our information willy-nilly.
Mass surveillance isn't an effective tool in a War on Terror - but it's been transformed rather handily into a tool on a War on the American People. When our own government decides we, the citizens of the U.S., are the enemy, we have a problem. It's time we fixed it!
You can Fight 215 and secure your rights to free speech and privacy!
- Libraries, Books, Writers, & Suchlike
- Lanny Keller: Calls to cut library's tax base harkens to old idea that second-best is good enough for Baton Rouge "Libraries are, above all, educational institutions. It’s almost a mathematical proposition: The less we spend on books in libraries, the more we’ll spend later on cells in prisons."
- HC US 'to return to full agency' on e-books Prepare for the next Amazon war.
- The Radical Vision of Toni Morrison
- LeVar Burton keeps the sunlight shining through the Reading Rainbow
- Famous novelist Salman Rushdie gave To Kill a Mockingbird 3 stars on Goodreads
- April 9, 1859: Mark Twain receives steamboat pilot’s license
- Net & Tech
- Why John Oliver Can't Find Americans Who Know Edward Snowden's Name (It's Not About Snowden)
- Kickstarter rejected over half of DMCA claims filed against it in 2014
- A New Internet Domain: Extortion Or Free Speech?
- Amazon files first-ever suit over fake product reviews, alleges Calif. man sold fraudulent praise
- Chicago man sues Facebook over facial recognition use in “Tag Suggestions”
- How the U.S. thinks Russians hacked the White House Related: Russia dismisses claim it hacked White House
- Walter Scott’s Death Is a Tragic Reminder of How Important It Is to Film Police Related: Phone Cameras and Apps Help Speed Calls for Police Reform
- Science & Health
- A Dark Night Is Good For Your Health
- What is going on in your brain when you sleep?
- Can You Get a Food Allergy From a Blood Transfusion?
- Rise of deadly radon gas in Pennsylvania buildings linked to fracking industry
- Ocean ‘dead zones’ are spreading – and that spells disaster for fish
- We can avoid mass extinction, but time is running out
- Why Ocean Energy Needs A Cyberinfrastructure To Thrive
- Signs of Alien Life Will Be Found by 2025, NASA's Chief Scientist Predicts
- News Corp.’s $1 Billion Plan to Overhaul Education Is Riddled With Failures "Tablet computers and an online curriculum were supposed to help revolutionize schools. That hasn't happened."
- In California: State Senate Committee Votes to End Vaccine Personal Belief Exemption
- Rand Paul's Campaign Website Misspelled 'Education' Oops.
- Other (Serious Stuff)
- Judge reduces mandatory sentence for Santa Ana man in child sex assault I do not understand what this judge was thinking...It's just gross.
- Walter Scott shooting witness Feidin Santana reveals how he captured the video that saw police officer Michael Slager arrested
- Why Do We Keep Insisting That Poor People Need To Be Miserable?
- Political speech or corruption?
- Young (and Old) People: Do Not Be Fooled by Rand Paul
- Dzhokhar Tsarnaev Is Guilty on All 30 Counts in Boston Marathon Bombing
- Former Ferguson City Court Clerk who sent racist emails speaks out
- Other (Fun Stuff)
- Detroit-Area Woman, 115, Now Listed as World's Oldest Person
- The Signature Food From Every State Some of these are funny; some are accurate; some are funny AND accurate.